USGS - science for a changing world
California Water Science Center

Regional Hydrology

This website has been archived. For more up to date information on Basin Characterization Model (BCM), please visit https://www.usgs.gov/centers/california-water-science-center/science/basin-characterization-model-bcm

Refinement of the Basin Characterization Model to Improve California Department of Water Resources Forecasting for Water Supply

The California Department of Water Resources (DWR) seeks new and innovative approaches to improve forecasting ability for water supply, including improved high-elevation precipitation estimates, long-term monitoring of ambient soil-moisture conditions, improved estimates of springtime runoff as an updateable tool, and monthly updated maps of estimated water supply, landscape stress and demand, and wildfire risk supported and verified by measurements and data links, to inform emergency response planning.

Objective and Scope

The objectives of this work are to improve climate data to drive the Basin Characterization Model (BCM), which will be refined to improve estimates of spring snowmelt and runoff, and develop products useful for forecasting water-supply needs under extreme conditions, such as drought.

Science Plan

We propose to address the improvement of DWR's forecasting ability for water supply with 5 tasks that rely initially on existing models or datasets; the models will be refined, the results interpreted, and final products will be developed for use by DWR and/or the public. The spatial extent of the project is the State of California, except for task 4, which highlights the Sierra Nevada. The five tasks are to (1) revise high-resolution precipitation estimates to benefit seasonal runoff forecasting, (2) revise soil-moisture parameterization to improve seasonal forecast simulation, (3) evaluate/develop a soil-moisture monitoring strategy, (4) assimilate Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) snow-water equivalent (SWE) estimates into the BCM for water-balance simulations, and (5) develop situational status maps to support emergency response intelligence (ER Intel) activities. Documentation will be provided in a journal article on the influence of soils on spring snowmelt, including descriptions of the methodology to revise the Parameter-elevation Regressions on Independent Slopes Model (PRISM) climate dataset and a plan for monitoring soil moisture statewide; documentation to accompany a model version delivered to DWR that assimilates snow-water-equivalent data and updates the BCM monthly, and a updateable website with drought conditions for water supply, the landscape, and wildfire.

Relevance and Benefits

The proposed work directly addresses several aspects of the USGS Science Strategy for the Decade, 2007-2017 (U.S. Geological Survey, 2007), specifically "Understanding Ecosystems and Predicting Ecosystem Change, Climate Variability and Change". In addition to uncertainties about water supply, wildfires in California are becoming more prevalent as a result of changing climate. Land and resource managers are seeking understanding as to the most scientifically defensible strategies for successful water supply and resource management. This study will provide refined tools to estimate hydrologic processes that result in more certainty regarding water supply, and key insights into the responses of the hydrologic system to extremes in climate and climate change.

Approach

To meet the needs of DWR to improve their ability to forecast watershed runoff and water supply, we propose five components to our project:

We will refine our spatial downscaling approach for climate to improve Parameter-elevation Regressions on Independent Slopes Model (PRISM) high-elevation precipitation estimates to enable accurate snow-water equivalent (SWE) simulations. We will rely on snow pillows, Jet Propulsion Labortory/snow-water equivalent (JPL/SWE) maps, and Airborne Snow Observatory (ASO) maps as indicators of precipitation volume, particularly at the high elevations, along with cooperative stations from National Weather Service (NWS) Cooperative Observer Program (COOP, www.ncdc.noaa.gov/), Remote Automated Weather Stations (RAWS, www.raws.dri.edu/), and California Irrigation Management Information System (CIMIS, www.cimis.water.ca.gov/).

  • Data collection: including snow and precipitation sensors, map of change in snowpack indicating high-elevation increases, correlations with high elevation observations (Mote, 2006; Andrews, 2012), identification of basins where measured snow is greater than PRISM precipitation, JPL estimates of snow water equivalent using ASO data
  • Develop plan for downscaling and verification
  • Re-grid PRISM data with improved methodology for 1950-2016 and illustrate improved fits to measured/observed data

We have developed a conceptual model of the contribution of soil moisture to spring runoff and now have seven years of soil moisture monitoring to support the concepts. The drought conditions have provided opportunities to refine the simulation tools for accuracy in calculating the water balance and runoff, including revisions in soil depth to better reflect rooting zones. Preliminary analyses have been done for locations in the Russian River, but Yosemite locations have not yet been accessed for assessment of the drought years 2015 and 2016. We will extend these analyses to all available data (Hydrometeorological Testbed, HMT; National Resource Conservation Service, NRCS; Critical Zone Observatories (CZO); Scripps Institution of Oceanography) to extrapolate across the state. Prior to completing the documentation, we will incorporate these validation efforts and improve simulation tools for spring forecasting.

  • Collect soil-moisture data at locations across the state to provide time-series data with which to calibrate the revised dry-out capability in the BCM as a function of varying climatic water deficit (CWD).
  • Conduct sensitivity analyses of soil moisture below wilting point for 2013-2015 with changes in CWD. Develop drying curves associated with soil types or properties statewide.
  • Develop approach to improve estimates of rooting depth, incorporating new soil layer, and using estimates of actual evapotranspiration (such as the METRIC, Sebal, or Normalized Difference Vegetation Index [NDVI] data).
  • Validate runoff estimates using improved precipitation data and model revisions with reservoir inflows and streamflow data for selected locations.

An approach has been developed to optimize monitoring locations that have been tested in the Lake Mendocino basin with the intent of distribution throughout the Russian River basin. Similarly for Hetch Hetchy, using the updated soil properties maps and model revisions, and relying on the Dana Meadows and Gin Flat soil potential/moisture data as forecasting tools, we will determine conditions under which these data can be used to constrain forecasting simulations, evaluate uncertainties, and identify additional locations to provide improved forecasts in conjunction with ASO data for the upper Tuolumne (Hetch Hetchy) basin in the San Joaquin river basin. This approach would then be applied statewide to optimize soil-moisture monitoring strategies for early warning purposes.

  • Analyze conditions in the Hetch Hetchy basin using soil-moisture data, test utility for forecasting, and identify additional soil-moisture locations that would significantly improve forecasts.
  • Identify and prepare data layers similar to those used in the Lake Mendocino basin exercise for the State of California, considering the varying differences in sensitivities to extremes across the state (both drought and flood are necessary for purposes of early warning), and using omission overlays for urban, agriculture, and other unrealistic locations to monitor soil moisture. Highlight reservoirs and other locations of interest for forecasting runoff and CWD, and include existing infrastructure, preserves, and ongoing soil-moisture data collection platforms.
  • Perform exercise to locate about 200 soil moisture stations using weighted average binning (discuss with DWR to determine the optimum number and locations of interest).
  • If data allow, we will consider how and where to monitor springs in conjunction with wells to monitor groundwater conditions.

Having the dry soil conditions included in the revised modeling tools (item 2), we will apply monthly revisions to the daily BCM, assimilate JPL/SWE data for the entire Sierra Nevada (and the Pit River basin in the Sacramento River basin in northeastern California if the JPL data allows), and recalibrate daily models to accumulate SWE and accurately reflect the water balance for spring snow melt. Results for 2000-2014 will be compared to the 8-station and 5-station indices and measured streamflow throughout the Sierra. Building on previous work, we'll tie the SWE in with antecedent hydrologic conditions and provide an improved forecasting tool for spring runoff volumes. We will further calibrate the solar radiation function using the JPL and ASO data available for the Tuolumne basin, which would be included in the final documentation.

  • Collect all data and revise daily BCM.
  • Provide calibration results to illustrate improved snow accumulation and melt capability for Sierra Nevada basins and how it matches JPL snow covered area and snow-water equivalent. Identify additional issues with simulations of snow, indicate the need to have JPL include the Pit River basin, and assess the need to include eastern Sierras in the daily modeling.
  • Evaluate differences between using a solar flag or not, and if it improves estimates in the upper Tuolumne.
  • Develop map of spatially distributed snow parameters.

Develop a template for a California statewide webpage with monthly updated situational status maps that will inform emergency response and planning. It needs to be monthly, reproducible, validated or correlated to local information, and not rely on current conditions of the managed system. The webpage may be produced in conjunction with the Western Regional Climate Center administered by NOAA in Reno at the Desert Research Institute that hosts the Southwest Climate and ENvironmental Information Collaborative (SCENIC), or on the USGS California Water Science Center home page. This determination hasn't been made yet.

  • Determine needs for ER Intel iteratively with DWR.
  • Design template to include maps representing status of water supply, landscape drought and natural demand, wildfire risk and potentially reservoirs and groundwater conditions. Determine necessary explanations, validation information, associated information and links.
  • Develop approach to represent cumulative climatic water deficit over time on a grid-cell basis.
  • Collect and analyze forage-condition data to illustrate relevance with CWD.
  • Develop validation exercises, including both water use and landscape health/stress:
    • Vegetation drought response index and CWD.
    • Cumulative Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) or Enhanced Vegetation Index (EVI) and CWD.
    • Changes in groundwater recharge and corresponding groundwater levels.
    • Discussion of CWD used to illustrate increases in population and agricultural water demand as a result of warming climates.
    • Demonstrate ability to use BCM simulated recharge plus runoff to reflect water supply using measured data, comparisons with reservoir inflows and soil-water storage, etc.
    • Develop framework for simple spot-check validation (perhaps through provided links to measured soil moisture and SWE station indices).
    • Investigate the possibility or usability of a drought severity binning approach. Possible example is using CWD and BCM estimated recharge plus runoff in percentiles according to historical conditions; as an example, compare with historical archives of the U.S. Drought Monitor.
    • Because soil-water content is correlated to forage condition statewide, collect foragecondition data from Mel George (University of California, Davis emeritus) to validate against BCM indices. Link to soil-moisture data for purposes of early warning.

Cooperating Agencies

California Department of Water Resources


References

Andrews ED (2012) Hydrology of the Sierra Nevada Network national parks: Status and trends. Natural Resource Report NPS/SIEN/NRR-2012/500. National Park Service, Fort Collins, Colorado. 196p.

Mote PW (2006) Climate-driven variability and trends in mountain snowpack in western North America. Journal of Climate 19: 6209-6220.

U.S. Geological Survey, 2007, Facing tomorrow's challenges-U.S. Geological Survey science in the decade 2007- 2017: U.S. Geological Survey Circular 1309, x + 70 p.